Cart 0
Cart 0

In the ring it's crochet v knitting. But who is the heavyweight? > Crochet Circle Podcast > Blog 4

• Fay Dashper-Hughes • CCP Blog 4 • compare crochet to knitting • crochet stitches and knitting stitches • crochet v knitting • does crochet use more yarn? • no crochet doesn't use more yarn • weights of crochet and knitting • what uses more yarn crochet or knitting?

Crochet v Knitting - who is the heavyweight?

Is the urban myth that crochet uses more yarn than knitting true?

As a relatively new crocheter (almost two years) there are certain facts that have been passed on to me.  One such fact is that crochet uses more yarn than knitting.  Now, I'm not normally one to swim the tide with the other fish - I generally like to make my own mind up about things and I like facts, especially if I have done the work behind my understanding.  For some reason I took the fact that crochet uses more yarn than knitting as gospel.

I can't really trace why it was that I decided to look at the evidence behind this, but it is probably because of my work on The Crochet Circle Podcast that made me want to dig into this topic further.  

So, I thought back to my Standard Grade Chemistry and Physics exams and pondered what the best methodology would be.  

Equipment

Initially I created tensions squares in two different yarn weights and when they were finished and the results were in, I had a look around to see how others had tackled this topic.  There were a few different approaches and some were similar to my methodology.  One of the questions asked was whether there was a difference in lace weight yarns also.  If you have listened to Episode 4 - A Crochet Journey of The Crochet Circle Podcast, you will already understand my new found utter dislike for using small hooks and needles.  But, being a conscientious sort of a person, I also created tension squares in lace weight (grrrrrrrr with a bit more grrrrr on the side!).


Here is what I crocheted and knitted with:   

Knitting yarn weight, type, hook, and needle size comparison chart.

For each of the above weights I knitted a tension square in stocking stitch and one in garter stitch. For crochet I created squares in double, half treble and treble crochet and cut their tails to the same lengths (2.5cm).

As hard as I tried I couldn't make exact 6" by 6" squares but that was taken into account when I was working through the methodology.

Crochet vs. knitting swatches in various shades of blue and teal yarn.

Method

So, I have 15 tension not-squares ready to measure and weigh.  My good kitchen scales can measure down to one tenth of a gram and the dimensions (width and length) of each square were measured to a millimeter.

I plugged all of the weights, widths and lengths into my excel spread sheet and applied the following logic:

  • By multiplying the width and length of each tension square I know what the number of cm2 is.
  • By dividing the weight of each tension square by the overall cm2, I can work out what 1cm squared would weigh.    
  • I can then use the 1cm squared weight to tell me what a 5cm x 5cm (2" x 2") sample area would weigh for each square in each yarn weight.  I used a 5 x 5 area because it is a familiar area for people to relate to because it is used for gauging tension for both knitting and crochet. 

Results

The results are below for each yarn weight:

Comparison of crochet stitch yarn weights per 25cm²: stocking stitch lightest, double crochet heaviest.

 Infographic comparing weight of double knitting stitches per 25cm sq: stocking, treble, half treble, garter, double crochet.

 

Chart comparing chunky yarn weight per 25cm² for different crochet and knitting stitches.

I also looked at the average (across all three yarns weights) percentage increase of yarn used per 25cm2 for the following:

Treble crochet - 31% more yarn than stocking stitch

Garter stitch - 51% more yarn than stocking stitch

Half treble - 45% more yarn than stocking stitch

Double crochet - 74% more yarn than stocking stitch

Given that treble crochet is consistently the next lightest stitch to use, I applied the same logic as above using treble as the baseline:

Garter stitch - 13% more yarn than treble crochet

Half treble - 10% more yarn than treble crochet

Double crochet - 31% more yarn than treble crochet

 

Conclusions

It is a gross generalisation to say that crochet uses more yarn than knitting.  If you look at some of the other reviews that I have linked to you will see quotes of three times the amount!

Three results were consistent throughout my study.  Stocking stitch was the lightest, treble crochet was next and double crochet was always the heaviest.  

There is very little in it between garter stitch and half treble which is why the position of those varies across the three yarn weights.  

At the heart of this though, what I am really hoping for is that crochet isn't seen as the heavyweight between the two crafts.  If this also encourages crocheters to look to buy yarn with a higher wool content then even better.  I suspect that some crocheters use acrylic because it has been ingrained in them that crochet uses more yarn and is therefore a more expensive hobby than knitting.  

Anything that encourages the use of renewable materials such as wool rather than synthetic fibres derived from fossil fuels is always going to get the thumbs up from me!

Caveats

1 - The overall weight of each of the squares was used which means that the weight of the cast on/cast off and crochet chain are also included.  If I was going to do this experiment again I would deduct the weight of the initial crochet chains, cast on and cast off so that on the actual stitches were being weighed.

2 - Tension changes from day to day. I created each of the five squares for each yarn weight on the same day over the course of three days (DK, then chunky, then lace weight (grrrr)) to try to ensure that my tension was as even as possible.   I couldn't find a better way around this.

Links to other approaches on crochet v knitting weights:

Here is how the lovely Joanne Scrace of Not So Granny approached it - http://notsogranny.com/2014/07/does-crochet-really-use-more-yarn-than-knitting.html 

I found this Compile Yarn blog that uses a stitch count methodology and creates similar results to my test - http://compileyarn.blogspot.co.uk/2012/03/knitting-vs-crochet-does-crochet-really.html

And I also quite liked this approach which also looks at Tunisian crochet - http://thing4string.blogspot.co.uk/2007/01/unraveling-truth.html 

← Older Post Newer Post →

  • Furniture moving on

    Thank you so much for sharing all this wonderful info with the how-to’s! It is so appreciated!
    https://abrir.link/neCII
    https://bit.ly/3o2IBcy
    https://bit.ly/3ROv71y
    https://bit.ly/3WmrELl
    https://bit.ly/4b6aRkc
    https://bit.ly/4bqz3xG
    https://2u.pw/7p9EBY9
    https://2u.pw/yxjqpH4
    https://2u.pw/NPKsEsd
    https://2u.pw/jVHsVc6
    https://2u.pw/FCZK7oT
    https://rentry.co/c838re94
    https://nopaste.paefchen.net/1984779
    https://ko-fi.com/moversintaif
    https://moversintaif.edublogs.org
    https://www.edocr.com/user/jeddahnakl
    https://rentry.co/c838re94
    https://www.reddit.com/r/pnn4230/
    https://www.reddit.com/user/PomegranateLife1229/
    https://rb.gy/oegdmm
    https://rb.gy/8zuqxs
    https://rb.gy/tm6krp
    https://rb.gy/oegdmm
    https://rb.gy/8zuqxs
    https://rb.gy/tm6krp
    https://tempaste.com/moversintaif
    https://justpaste.it/f94vk
    https://justpaste.it/f94vk
    https://justpaste.it/avn1a
    https://justpaste.it/agvkp
    https://justpaste.it/c7d5w
    https://justpaste.it/a1881
    https://justpaste.it/agvkp
    https://rentry.co/c838re94

    https://cutt.ly/MwCxTHEc
    https://ko-fi.com/moversintaif
    https://paste.ee/p/Q0bc3
    https://rentry.co/fo3963yc
    https://rentry.co/fo3963yc/raw
    https://www.pinterest.com/dammam_pmm1
    https://medium.com/cleaning-company https://medium.com/pnn9299
    https://medium.com/pvv9499 https://medium.com/pnn6766
    https://medium.com/pnn1559 https://medium.com/jeddahnakl
    https://moversintaif.edublogs.org
    https://www.edocr.com/user/jeddahnakl
    https://rentry.co/c838re94
    https://nopaste.paefchen.net/1985088
    https://nopaste.paefchen.net/1985086
    https://nopaste.paefchen.net/1984779
    https://www.behance.net/f7a8a5b3
    https://controlc.com/2354c315
    https://pastebin.com/5cVEFCwd
    https://goo.gl/iRWLXB
    https://goo.gl/53wgB4
    https://goo.gl/fkBcn8
    https://goo.gl/W74Wwp
    https://goo.gl/MKdvqr
    https://www.crokes.com/movinmakkah/info/
    https://yamcode.com/dlyl-shrkat-nkl-aafsh-bgd
    https://hackmd.io/Csjh1MqTaum7CUWa8Q3lA?view
    https://hackmd.io/moversint/S1uyc369p
    https://cutt.ly/4wCjlqaU
    https://walling.app/H0nJyJwmmyuK1A2saCBQ/-
    https://bitbin.it/lIf4wziu/
    https://bitbin.it/BHOujxrS/
    https://bitbin.it/v00s5VGQ/
    https://apaste.info/QgoR
    https://commie.io/#efYiw5LZ
    https://controlc.com/20018b5d
    https://tempaste.com/afashdammam
    https://tempaste.com/transfer-furniture-dammam
    https://linktr.ee/movinmakkah
    https://movinmakkah.livejournal.com/306.html
    https://moversinriyadh.my.canva.site/moversinriyadh
    https://pastebin.com/dVaMZ4Zc
    https://paste.ee/p/SFOIM
    https://oktob.io/pnn9799
    https://oktob.io/posts/81103
    https://oktob.io/posts/82001
    https://oktob.io/posts/81294
    https://oktob.io/posts/81200
    https://oktob.io/posts/81107
    https://oktob.io/posts/81211
    https://app.daily.dev/posts/bx5oWFhIu
    https://taplink.cc/moversintaif
    https://www.tumblr.com/movinmakkah
    https://movinmakkah.simdif.com/
    https://paste.myst.rs/cj1uyr2j
    https://paste.myst.rs/yaj8vldp
    https://apaste.info/WK90
    https://pastebin.com/Sm58m4CC
    https://rentry.co/movinmakkah
    https://www.pastery.net/utstrm/
    https://pastelink.net/2az9iz5u
    https://pastie.org/p/02RWjYENqEntsphazPgROC/raw
    https://www.diigo.com/user/pnn9499/b/738040873
    https://tempaste.com/servicesinTaif
    https://paste.ee/p/rNypS
    https://pastelink.net/services%20in%20Taif
    https://paste.mozilla.org/m7EM4sUi
    https://paste.ee/p/kvMBq
    https://paste.rs/Ual13.txt
    https://nopaste.ceske-hry.cz/405960
    https://devpost.com/moversintaif
    https://www.youtube.com/moversintaif
    https://www.pinterest.com/moversintaif/
    https://www.pinterest.com/roqaya65/
    https://www.wattpad.com/user/jeddahnakl
    https://www.wattpad.com/user/linkedmohamed
    https://t.co/bEnKpmhOua
    https://rentry.co/5qunfauv
    https://rentry.co/6szh6378
    https://pastelink.net/jv497vbs
    https://longbets.org/user/jeddahnakl/
    https://apaste.info/LTmW
    https://rentry.co/v9enh7g6
    https://www.instagram.com/mecca_054/
    https://paste.ee/p/7nHsj
    https://paste.feed-the-beast.com/view/e8c5a8fe
    https://rentry.co/owf8z7x6
    https://archive.org/details/@user_27767
    https://archive.org/details/dammam-movers
    https://hackmd.io/-HiH-TvPQQG4zUUI0Il3eA
    https://hackmd.io/YJc4k7QiRlGBTxSH    ix6Hg

    https://hackmd.io/movinmakk/r1WjXP-jp https://hackmd.io/_Csjh1MqTaum7CUWa8Q3lA https://hackmd.io/movinmakk/HknekCQpa
    https://is.gd/zMEJDl
    https://is.gd/bdIzKb
    https://is.gd/IkUfsB
    https://is.gd/nXlMSI
    https://is.gd/zfkyFq
    https://is.gd/U1BdUe
    https://linkr.it/1mFylz
    https://linkr.it/4pMGZz
    https://linkr.it/297s0K
    https://linkr.it/4nuVcO
    https://linkr.it/13sKd3
    https://ben-kiki.org/ypaste/data/95199/index.html
    https://ben-kiki.org/ypaste/data/95200/index.html
    https://simp.ly/p/3ZbFV2
    https://sleekbio.com/moversintaif
    https://tinylink.net/3AQsw
    https://tinylink.net/I9O0u
    https://tinylink.net/PzN7W
    https://tinylink.net/9atci
    https://gurl.pro/-8hxf5
    https://gurl.pro/b2yxe1
    https://gurl.pro/ko-ui1
    https://rentry.co/622f8cod
    https://apaste.info/5T6x
    https://paste.kodi.tv/ewupusadan
    https://www.merexpression.com/jeddahnakl
    https://hackmd.io/Z0CQDnGeQGGWjwLYPiqHkg
    https://bandori.party/user/192402/bbnn7592/
    https://dojour.us/u/pnn9299
    https://dojour.us/e/24030-/preview
    https://www.mixcloud.com/pnn9299/
    https://about.me/moversintaif1
    https://www.furaffinity.net/user/moversintaif/
    https://taplink.cc/moversinqassim
    https://rentry.co/moversintaif
    https://hackmd.io/MoversinJeddah/SJlHOO4MA https://movinmakkah.livejournal.com/ https://mastodon.social/jazanmovers
    https://www.tumblr.com/transferfurniturejeddah
    https://rentry.co/6wv78gdb
    https://hackmd.io/@moversint/BJ5PIGX70
    https://ln.run/y2ztq

    Read more: https://kagitumbahs.webnode.page/guestbook/
    https://apaste.info/LTmW
    https://pastelink.net/v864u2wf
    https://rentry.co/yn62aq7y
    https://rentry.co/9gokq9qx
    https://rentry.co/e975iq3q
    https://bitbin.it/Ufe2Mip4/
    https://bitbin.it/9aZeYGuP/
    https://rentry.co/ceqb9ea5
    https://hackmd.io/LlP4bDsuSyujt0cJ19V8vA
    https://taplink.cc/naqel_afsh_taif
    https://rentry.co/7r4tqvn9
    https://rentry.co/tuwczb25
    https://rentry.co/bxm67g24
    https://rentry.co/gwpyq7ne
    https://pastelink.net/px3i64ri
    https://etextpad.com/6zyf4amreh
    https://etextpad.com/iiscddm2ik
    https://abrir.link/neCII

  • Furniture moving companies in Taif on

    Furniture transportation and storage services in Taif, Jeddah, Dammam, and Jubail at the best prices. Packaging of the finest and most luxurious types. The price is determined upon knowing the furniture, floors, and distance.
    https://sites.google.com/site/movinmakkah
    https://sites.google.com/site/movinmakkah/moversinmecca
    https://sites.google.com/site/movinmakkah/qassim-movers
    https://sites.google.com/site/movinmakkah/moversinahsa
    https://sites.google.com/site/movinmakkah/jeddah
    https://sites.google.com/site/movinmakkah/madina
    https://sites.google.com/site/movinmakkah/takhazaynintabuk
    https://sites.google.com/site/movinmakkah/movers-in-khulais
    https://sites.google.com/site/movinmakkah/movinginjeddah-samer
    https://sites.google.com/site/movinmakkah/moving-furniture-in-alkhobar

    https://sites.google.com/site/movinmakkah/riyadh
    https://sites.google.com/site/movinmakkah/slricom
    https://sites.google.com/site/movinmakkah/mecca-movers
    https://sites.google.com/site/movinmakkah/taif

    https://sites.google.com/site/moversintaif/
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversintaif/furniture-movers-qatif
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversintaif/makkah
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversintaif/dammam-movers
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversintaif/moversinriyadh
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversintaif/afsh
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversintaif/moversinqassim

    https://sites.google.com/site/moversintaif/movers-ahsa
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversintaif/cleaningtabuk
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversintaif/cleaningindammam
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversintaif/jeddah
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversintaif/riyadh
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversintaif/dammam
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversintaif/furnituremovers-qassim
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversintaif/alkhobar

    https://sites.google.com/site/moversintaif/cleaning-carpet-tabuk
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversintaif/almadina
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversintaif/tabuk
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversintaif/yanbu
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversintaif/rabigh
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversintaif/jubail
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversintaif/najran
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversintaif/abha

    https://sites.google.com/site/afashdammam
    https://sites.google.com/site/afashdammam/toqassim
    https://sites.google.com/site/afashdammam/transfer-furniture-riyadh
    https://sites.google.com/site/afashdammam/takhazayn-aldamam
    https://sites.google.com/site/afashdammam/al-hasa-cleaning
    https://sites.google.com/site/afashdammam/alahsa
    https://sites.google.com/site/afashdammam/movingfurniture-qatif
    https://sites.google.com/site/afashdammam/movingfurniture-zahran
    https://sites.google.com/site/movingfurnitureinmecca
    https://sites.google.com/site/movingfurnitureinmecca/cleaninginmecca
    https://sites.google.com/site/movingfurnitureinmecca/gomoom-movers

    https://sites.google.com/site/movinginmeccariyadh
    https://sites.google.com/site/movinginmeccariyadh/jeddah

    https://sites.google.com/site/moversinnajran
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversinnajran/dammam
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversinnajran/jubail
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversinnajran/riyadh
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversinnajran/transfere-riyadh

    https://sites.google.com/site/moversalbaaha
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversalbaaha/taif
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversalbaaha/dammam
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversalbaaha/description
    https://sites.google.com/site/moversalbaaha/taiftoelbaha

    https://sites.google.com/site/transferjazanjeddah
    https://sites.google.com/site/transferjazanjeddah/riyadh
    https://sites.google.com/site/transferjazanjeddah/dammam
    https://sites.google.com/site/transferjazanjeddah/habitat

    https://sites.google.com/site/movingfurnitureinmakkah
    https://sites.google.com/site/movingfurnitureinmakkah/yanbu
    https://sites.google.com/site/movingfurnitureinmakkah/qassim

    https://sites.google.com/site/transfertojeddah
    https://sites.google.com/site/transfertojeddah/khamismushait

    https://sites.google.com/site/rabighalalameya
    https://sites.google.com/site/rabighalalameya/tabuk
    https://sites.google.com/site/rabighalalameya/riyadh

  • Gabriella on

    Tһis post оffers cⅼear idea foг the neѡ viewers of blogging,
    that atually hоw tо ԁo blogging.

    Ƭake a look at my web site :: basetools.sk alternative

Leave a comment